Disclaimer - This post contains broad generalizations about professions. It is not meant to offend anyone, but probably will. Most likely, the broad generalizations do not apply to the intelligent, sophisticated people that read this blog.
Yes, it's true. Lawyers are greater than Doctors. But let's be clear here, I'm not talking about actual Doctors. An actual Doctor is someone who studies some very specific subject matter and is only granted the title "Dr." after adding something new to the field and defending it to a group of experts. You know, PhD's - real doctors. Doctor comes from the latin doctoris, meaning teacher.
What I'm talking about in this post is Physicians. Why they are granted the title Doctor is beyond me. For some reason, in the 19th century, they got jealous of real Doctors and started granting themselves the same title. And though they are MD's, and Lawyers are JD's, you don't see people going around calling Lawyers things like "Dr. Hoy" or "Dr. Ck." Not to diminish the accomplishments of Attorneys, I'm sure Law School is difficult and it takes a certain kind of mix of logical analysis and hard work to be a successful lawyer.
Physicians on the other hand (and PharmD's more so), just piss me off. They demand to be called "Dr." though they are not adding anything new to the field, MD/PhD's withstanding. To be a successful "medical practitioner" takes a certain kind of person. A hard working, memorizing person. This is not to say there are not highly intelligent Physicians out there, but just to say high intelligence does not seem to be a requirement to pursuing an MD degree.
I know many Physicians, and some are very intelligent, and some are complete idiots. Most lawyers I know are pretty smart people, and I can't think of one that I would consider an idiot. Plenty of them are assholes, but with the exception of Hoy's boss, I don't think you can get away with stupidity in the legal world. You just won't last very long.
The simple fact is, I guess I want any attorney I hire to be an asshole. Their job is to be the best, hard nosed, fuck you advocate they can for their clients. When I hire a lawyer, I don't want a nice guy to be representing me, I want to win the damn thing.
Physicians are more of a drain on society than people think. In particular, I speak of General Practitioners, or, Primary Care Physicians (PCP). I think this is where many of the dumb ones end up. In general, Physicians are not thinkers. They are memorizers. All medical school consists of is memorizing many, many, many texts. Residency might be where some thinking comes in. Watching, learning, and practicing with others in your selected specialty is what makes for a great surgeon, or psychiatrist. Though there is some of this in medical school during your two years of rotations, it seems to me that the residency is where real learning can happen. The rotations in years 3 and 4 of medical school just serve to weed out people from different specialties.
Are PCP's the weed outs? I don't know, maybe it's really competitive to get a General Practitioner residency, because everyone want the great hours. Maybe not, because the AMA seems to want to encourage people away from specialties. All I do know is that my experience* has shown me that PCP's are shitty, greater than thou, non-caring assholes.
When I hire a lawyer, that's what I want. It is not what I want when I hire a physician.
Example the First -
A year ago I had a very sore throat, fever, etc. I made an appointment with my PCP for 9:30am. I arrive on time. I wait an hour to be taken to the examination room. Once there, I read a magazine. I fall asleep in the chair and wake up at 1:00PM. No one has seen me yet. Furious, I storm out and demand my co-pay back. They assure me I was just about to be seen, as the "doctors" had just returned from lunch. This made me flip out on them. They gave my co-pay back and I left.
Example the Second -
My sister has two friends who have the same pediatrician for their children. One of them must go in to the doctors office with her child every time something is wrong. The other one only has to call the doctor and they will prescribe over the phone without making them come in for a visit. What the hell is going on here? Well, one of them has insurance that requires a co-pay, and one has insurance that does not require a co-pay. You figure out the rest.
Example the Last -
I have a rash of Excema on my lower leg. My insurance does not require me get referrals from my PCP, so generally, if I have an issue, I just go to a specialist in that area. It is difficult to make an appointment with a dermatologist, and my appointment was over a month away. I decided to call my PCP to see if it would be worthwhile to come in there in the meantime if there was something they could do for me. They first berated me on the phone for not coming in to them more often, and then told me yes, I should definitely come in if the excema was really bothering me and I couldn't wait until seeing the dermatologist.
I arrived, paid my $20 co-pay, and was seen relatively promptly. I showed then the problem and was then berated again for 5 minutes about how I should come in more often. I asked if they could just prescribe me a topical cream to alleviate the inflammation, letting them know I have used Betamethazone (a topical cortico-steriod) in the past with good results.
"No, you need to go to a dermatologist."
"I know, but I was told to come here in the meantime."
"Well, I can give you a list of Dermatologists to call."
"Then why the fuck did I come here? I don't need referrals, and I know how to use a phone book."
"Well, there is nothing we can do, I suggest you call a dermatologist."
"Thanks a bunch asshole. Next time, I'll stay at home and burn a $20 bill. It will save me 2 hours. Fuck you."
The PCP business is a god damn racket. There needs to be a class action law suit against the AMA. All that is cared about is the co-pay. They are in business to take $20 from you. I would gladly pay $100 for actual service. But we are forced to pay $20 for none. I'm lucky, in that I don't need referrals, but most medial insurance requires patients to first go to a PCP and waste time and money. The AMA and HMO's are in cahoots in what is probably the largest "legal" racketeering outfit in the history of the nation.
This is why lawyers > "doctors."
*I have worked at a law firm for 4 years, a large hospital system for 5 years, and an HMO for 1 year, so I do have a bit of experience in dealing with these groups of people. I won't even get started on the HMO's, I had to quit that job because of how evil they are.